Digital Court Reporting

The Ninth Circuit Court’s automated court reporters are using cutting edge technology to monitor, record, transcribe, and annotate court proceedings. The Ninth Circuit's new courthouse anotatation.jpg (15417 bytes)was constructed with network and audio/visual infrastructure that  allows a single Automated Court Reporter (ACR) to monitor and annotate up to four courtrooms at one time from a centralized location.

How It Works
Starting in each courtroom, an analogue mixer receives the signals from as many a six microphones. The signals are mixed down to four channels of audio, plus one channel for backup, and are transmitted over several sets of twisted pair to the ACR server room, located in another building. The servers receive the signals and  encode the audio digitally by using a special card.  The audio is then streamed to the server’s RAID hardservers2.jpg (14487 bytes) drives, where it can be played back from any workstation running special software. One server is used as the primary machine and records four channels of audio. If the primary server crashes for some reason, then the backup server still records a single channel feed from the courtroom, so there is no loss of testimony. From a main control center, the ACRs can access each of the courtrooms and turn on and off the recordings, as well as make annotations for each case in each courtroom. Additionally, the ACRs can   can remotely monitor all court proceedings through video cameras mounted in each courtroom.

The Software
The Ninth Circuit uses software called FTR (For the Record). FTR has several different features that allow ACRs to annotate, turn on and off the recording in the courtroom, and switch between different courtrooms. There are also features that allow ACRs to transcribe as well as Judges to review testimony in their chambers by using a browsing module. You can check out FTRs latest by visiting their site at http://www.ftr.org/

The Process
Each morning, the ACRs come in and fire up the annotator software and connect to each courtroom. They have a list of the court dockets, so they know when court will begin in each courtroom. They also can tell if court is running on time, because they can check the video monitors in the courtroom. warning.jpg (15280 bytes)Once court starts, the clerk slides the case folder under the bar scanner in the courtroom, and the case number is automatically entered into the database and annotation record. The ACRs watch each courtroom on the monitors and switch back and forth between courtrooms making annotations. After the trial or hearing is over, in the courtroom the clerk slides the next case file under the bar scanner, and the next case begins.

Transcription
The servers’ disk drives are large enough to hold up to five days of audio, after which the audiotranscribe.jpg (15216 bytes) files are archived onto 4mm tape. If the audio hasn't been archived, a transcriptionist can access the audio directly from the servers hard drives, without the need of restoring data. If the audio has been archived, the ACR can lookup the tape number and restore the audio. Audio playback is controlled via foot pedals that plug into the back to their PC.

Hear comes the Judge
During breaks, before court , and/or court, the Judge can retire to his/her chamber and access the ACR system using their PC. They can access the database, find the case, and scroll down through the annotation, until they find the testimony they’re interested in hearing. Judges who take judgeftr.jpg (21756 bytes)over cases or aren’t familiar with a case, may choose to listen to the testimony rather than reading it. Testimony can also be played back in the courtroom via request from an attorney.

The Gear
FTR requires four large Digital servers running Windows NT 4.0. Each server requires 36GB of disk space, two tape drives. Each courtroom requires a PC that is accessible via remote control software called Timbuktu. Each annotator requires a PC, as well as each transcriber.

The Payoff
The Ninth Circuit was able to reduce the number of ACRs from 28 to 18 by putting this technology to work. In the past, each ACR was required to sit in court all day and record using standard tape machines. They would make annotations on paper, indicating the tape number for each entry. Now, one ACR can simultaneously monitor up to four hearings, depositions, or trials, at one time from a remote location. This not only reduced the number of ARCs required to maintain the court record, but it also reduced the physical number of people required to be in the courtroom each day.